Showing posts with label The Iliad Harry Potter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Iliad Harry Potter. Show all posts

Thursday, 10 February 2011

The Iliad - Books 11-24 - Thank Goodness!

Wow. I finished it. That's SUCH a relief! I never have to read it (in full) again! Not a huge amount happens in the second half - main points are that Achilles' BFF gets killed by Hector (the Trojan leader) so Achilles is really ragey and RAAAH... so he decides to fight Hector and manages to kill him and the Trojans get depressed and then that's it. Exciting. As I have nothing else to say about the general content of the poem, I shall get straight on to my random musings on it...
  • Firstly, the fight scenes are incredibly violent. If this was done as a film it could easily be an 18. Here is a particularly graphic quote: "clean through the heavy metal and bone the point burst / and the brains splattered all inside the casque". Charming. (Don't ask me what a casque is, I have no idea).
  • Book 11, line 452 - this dude called Diomedes has a pole stuck through his foot which goes through into the ground, but he is "never flinching". This made me think about a bit in the third Ergaon book called Brisingr by Christopher Paolini when a load of soldiers have been enchanted to not feel pain, instead they feel like they're being tickled... Yeah I just thought of that because it's quite a creepy, inhuman image, of someone just ignoring a crippling pain like that.
  • Book 11 AGAIN, line 579 - just a throwaway line about "wounded Lysander", but I was very concerned that it might be the same Lysander from A Midsummer Night's Dream and I felt very sorry for Hermia :(
  • Book 12, line 29 - this reminded me of Paradise Lost again. Here it says "nine days hurled their flood against the wall", and in PL, Satan and his pals are "hurled headlong" for "nine times the space that measures day and night". I think Milton liked this poem... strange man.
  • Book 18, line 690 - they mentioned someone called Daedalus and I was like OMG Diggle!! (as in Daedalus Diggle, a minor character in the Harry Potter series. Get with it guys).
So yeah those are my thoughts on The Iliad.

I also had to read a critcal essay on Homer by some ancient Trojan guy, and there was one bit which I thought was very interesting and can be applied to modern day life. He said,

"Most men are so completelty corrupted at heart by opinion that they would rather be notorious for the greatest calamities than suffer no ill and be unknown".

I thought that this kind of fits in with modern day celebrities - we see so many who will do anything to be famous *coughjordancough*, and they don't care why people know about them, just so long as everyone does. We should take after HazzaP who didn't want to be famous but made the best of it and came out pretty awesome in the end :]

Sunday, 6 February 2011

The Iliad - Books 1-10 - Why is it so hard to concentrate??

Well hello again! I've been reading The Iliad like I said, and well... I'm finding it difficult to pay attention so far, hopefully it'll get better. The first time I perked up was in Book 2 when it mentioned someone called Hermione and I was like, OMG Granger! But of course it wasn't referring to the loveable brainbox.

Maybe I should explain what The Iliad is about to those lucky people who haven't read it: it's basically about a short period in the Greek/Trojan War - you know the one with Helen of Troy, Achilles and the legendary Wooden Horse thing. It seems to be written in favour of the Achaeans (Greeks), but I always preferred the Trojans... not sure why. I know the poem is renouned and considered great literature, and I do appreciate the genius of Homer - I mean to create a poem that long (614 pages in my copy) and with all the wonderful metaphors and poetic language is amazing - but it's not exactly my favourite book. I got really annoyed with the treatment and objectification of women by pretty much all the male charcaters and took an instant dislike to Agamemnon because he's so angry, selfish and mean, however I like all the interactions between the gods and godesses - the poet seems sometimes to have shown them in a petty, childlike way: especially the resentment of Hera and Athena to Zeus.

Ok so here are a few things that I thought of when reading so far:
  • Book 4 line 50 and Book 8 lines 238-41 - the system of the gods seems pretty autocratic: Zeus is always reinforcing his power over the others, in Books 2 he says, "give me my way", and various times in Book 8 he brags how much stronger than the others he is, and how there's no way they can defeat him or rise against him. I don't know, it doesn't seem a very fair system.
  • Book 8 again - there is a point where they Trojans and Argives are fighting and the Trogans are winning so the Argives get scared. So they run to their ships to escape and a leader yells at them to run back and fight, then they get scared and run away again, and this keeps going on for mulitple times, and it was just like, SERIOUSLY GUYS?? Make your minds up! Good Grief.
  • Book 8 again, line 654 - There was a really good line here that went, "stallions waited for Dawn to mount her glowing throne". I just thought the imagery here was lovely, and the personification of dawn made me think of Fantasia - you know that Disney animation to classical music? Yeah there was a bit in there where Night glided over the sky as a woman, and I always loved that bit, so I thought about that here.
  • There's a heck of a lot of connections I found to Paradise Lost which I studied last year, and I'm not surprised because Milton was pretty into his classics.
I also had to read a chapter of a different books for another of my modules about the Theory of English, and there was a line that instantly made me think about Harry Potter. It was from something that Dante wrote (man, I sound so intellectual here!) saying, "in matters of great secrecy we should have few companions". OK is this not EXACTLY what Dumbledore was saying to Harry in Half Blood Prince when he told him to confide only in Ron and Hermione about the Horcrux mission? That's the whole reason the trio had to work it all out alone, because the more people who knew what they were up to, the more likely it was that Voldemort would find out. So Dante was right.

So I will continue to read The Iliad -I need to finish it by Thursday morning so I'll probably do a new post sometime around then... The next book is, unfortunately, The Aeneid which is apparently pretty much the same as this one but from the Trojans' point of view... oh the joys of English. Hopefully I'll get time to read something more light-hearted soon!